Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Auto-choke problem on 1.6 Montego

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Auto-choke problem on 1.6 Montego

    Bit of an odd one this, it gets murkier the more I investigate and do, and I now have a Montego 1600 with a seemingly kaput Auto Choke.

    From the end of February, there had been a seemingly random misfire while trying to accelerate in the higher gears. Random? It happened occasionally when the engine was warm/hot with the engine under load in the higher gears at engine speeds around 2000 to 3000rpm - the engine would seem to 'jolt' fleetingly then return to normal running in the early stages, then it became more of a 'loss of power' sometimes as the problem progressed over several hundred miles. Occasionally the rev counter would 'drop' but not very often. Easing the accelerator allowed acceleration to resume as it was before.

    Around 2 weeks ago, I resolved to get to the bottom of this problem. Various checks were made on the ignition system, and changing the Ignition ECU was the only thing that stopped the misfiring (there was a random misfire at idle, with the rev counter needle dropping for the duration as well, by this stage).

    But! Immediately on starting the engine for the second time with the 'new' (used) Ignition ECU (it has the same part number as the original one, from memory), I noticed that the temp gauge had started reading much lower and then the engine started idling faster at around 1600rpm. The idle speed dropped from the fast idle of 1600rpm to around 1300rpm pretty quickly and stayed there.

    Next morning, the car started beautifully, but the high idle speed of 1600rpm remained until the car had warmed up and then stopped in traffic, whence the revs dropped to 1300rpm and stayed there until the car was driven and stopped in traffic when the same pattern occured. The temp gauge shows the sort of readings where the engine would be coming off its fast idle after starting from cold.

    Removing the coolant temp sender plug caused the idle speed to drop, which threw me a little.

    Despite this, the car runs really well, but the fuel gauge is dropping a little faster than it usually would.

    Suspecting the fuel ECU to be faulty, fitting another (used) fuel ECU produced the same behaviour, and nor did fitting a used coolant temp sender make any noticeable difference either.

    The Fast Check showed the 'Stepper Motor HI' LED as well as the expected LEDs, so after checking for continuity in the wires between the fuel ECU connector and stepper motor plug and finding no breaks I changed the carb stepper motor for a used spare I have - and removing it from its carb unfortunately loosened the spindle so that the outer part could be turned by hand.

    Having reset the position of the hole in the outer part by eye, and fitted this stepper motor to the carb, the car runs beautifully when warm/hot but there is no 'throttle jacking' and the idle speed remains around 900rpm (the fast idle rod is 'out' a few mm, and just stays there) even when the coolant temp sender plug is disconnected. Meanwhile, the temp gauge reads low still.

    Wielding the Fast Check again, not only is the 'Stepper Motor HI' LED on still, but now the 'Coil' LED has gone out (it should be illuminated). And while the fuel ECU is disconnected the temp gauge still reads 1/4 with the Ignition Key at 'II', just as it did before the fuel ECU was disconnected (when the Ignition key is removed, the needle drops to Cold, as usual).

    Realising I now have a car that won't start in the morning, I am now back in the MG1600...

    I'd dearly like the keep the Auto Choke on the Montego, but a lack of time for the next week or so plus an MoT booked for Tuesday makes me lean towards fitting a manual choke and rewiring the temp gauge circuit just to get the car back on the road for now .

    Can anybody inspire me as to what might be going on and where to start checking? Thanks in advance .
    Rich Smith

    "Joe", aka "The Ryton Express", aka E838 VJO. Peugeot 309SR main car
    "Kryten", aka A560 SCW. Left hand drive MG Maestro 1600 'R' second in command
    "Fleagle", aka F929 NNA. Montego 1.6L saloon stored, status "doubts set in"
    "Cracow", aka CCW 925Y Maestro Vanden Plas - the oldest known to the Club stored, status "will fight another day - eventually"

    You can email me here

  • #2
    1600 auto choke

    I had a similar situation years ago my garage tryed various things without success.I then reluctently had it changed to manual which i hated as one i couldnt find a satisfactory position for the switch and i just would not accept that the auto choke problem couldn't be fixed.Any way sometime later i got hold of a s/h choke and had it rebulit by my local carb specialist.Found the stepper motor that came off the original cleaned it up and reconnected it to the choke.I then took off the one on the car and swapped it over with the re-built one and its worked ever since.The only other thing i did was to go back to the carb bloke for slight adjustment and had a new vac switch. maybe i was just lucky:laugh:
    Last edited by TLC; 1st May 2008, 10:55.
    Sure & steadfast.
    BMC/BL Rally 2008.First prize 1980s onward.
    1988 Montego Estate 1600L Atlantic Blue From new Daily runner
    1979 Triumph Dolomite 1500HL Pagent Blue From new 76.000 milesNow out of Hibination and into Restoration

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by TLC
      I had a similar situation years ago my garage tryed various things without success.I then flatulently had it changed to manual
      :laugh:

      I hope you kicked up a stink with that garage

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by Chris Y
        :laugh:

        I hope you kicked up a stink with that garage
        My typing Error [Reluctantly]:laugh: :laugh: Shouldnt type when n******d . Id just got back from a long trip .

        now edited
        Sure & steadfast.
        BMC/BL Rally 2008.First prize 1980s onward.
        1988 Montego Estate 1600L Atlantic Blue From new Daily runner
        1979 Triumph Dolomite 1500HL Pagent Blue From new 76.000 milesNow out of Hibination and into Restoration

        Comment


        • #5
          Hi Rich, I would do two things to start with, the 1st being I would refit temperarilly the faulty ignition ecu just to check if the temp guage is reading as it did before you swapped it. If the gauge starts working more normal again then you have two faulty ignition ecu's, all be it one causing a misfire the other affecting the temp gauge. If the temp gauge reads the same with both ecu's then you are ok to leave the replacement ecu without the misfire on the car.

          The second thing I would do is I would remove the stepper motor with the loose body as there could be several issues with that one, and fit another even if it means using the first one that showed a high resistance as it will be easier to diagnose a problem.

          When using the fuel management fast check you should always disconnect the ignition ecu as well because it can affect the readings. The stepper high led is very sensitive any poorish connection between the fast check and ecu plug will illuminate the led, also any very slight problem or dry connection at the bulkhead multi plug will illuminate the stepper leds. Just disturbing the wires or wiggling gently the harness can cause all manner of anomalies with the fast check readings so you will need to get all the contacts as clean and secure as possible to get the fast check to respond correctly.

          Hopefully we should be closer to getting the car running more as it should

          Gary

          Comment


          • #6
            Hi Gary, thanks for this - it's the sort of inspiration I'm looking for .

            Both ignition ECUs are on the car - the 'new' one is tie-wrapped onto the top of the original one so that is easy to change over. I'll give this a go, see how the temp gauge responds.

            Also, I will have access to several stepper motors this weekend, I was going to try connecting one (or more if needed) of these anyway, then fit it if it passes muster, so thanks for confirming my thoughts.

            I did disconnect the ignition ECU when using the fuel management Fast Check - thankfully I'd read the instructions before I'd started using it, or I would have just steamed in .

            Interesting comments about the bulkhead multi plug too - this had sort-of crossed my mind as well.


            I'll post up how this all pans out, but due to time pressures this will probably be Sunday.

            Actually, I wrote last night's post in a bit of a rush and bad mood (time spent working on the car that would have been better spent elsewhere), and thinking about these problems after some sleep - plus reading the replies to this thread - I am much reassured that there is nothing terminal wrong.

            Cheers again .
            Rich Smith

            "Joe", aka "The Ryton Express", aka E838 VJO. Peugeot 309SR main car
            "Kryten", aka A560 SCW. Left hand drive MG Maestro 1600 'R' second in command
            "Fleagle", aka F929 NNA. Montego 1.6L saloon stored, status "doubts set in"
            "Cracow", aka CCW 925Y Maestro Vanden Plas - the oldest known to the Club stored, status "will fight another day - eventually"

            You can email me here

            Comment


            • #7
              i believe thereare 2 types of instrument pack, one nippon seiki and the other lucus. Could the 2ecu you have be for cars with the different packs?

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by e692wtt
                Both ignition ECUs are on the car - the 'new' one is tie-wrapped onto the top of the original one so that is easy to change over.
                Ingenious Wonder where you may have picked that idea up from

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by Chris Y
                  Ingenious Wonder where you may have picked that idea up from
                  Couldn't possible comment ...

                  Originally posted by henoscr
                  i believe thereare 2 types of instrument pack, one nippon seiki and the other lucus. Could the 2ecu you have be for cars with the different packs?
                  I'd expect them to be plug 'n' play, to be honest, but an interesting idea .

                  ---

                  After much faffing about, it's the 'new' Ignition ECU at fault - on my car anyway. I have access to other Montego 1.6s so we can experiment and see if henoscr's idea holds water .

                  The 'Stepper Motor HI' LED lighting up was a pink fish - it was a poor connection between the Fast Check 'fuel management' unit and the Fuel ECU connector . Application of pressure soon put the LED out - the resistances between the Orange/White cable and the others to the Stepper Motor at the connector, with the Stepper Motor connected, were all around 15ohms on the 'broken' (loose-spindled) Stepper Motor - and the original one, and both replacements we fitted in turn...

                  Reconnecting the 'original' Ignition ECU got it all working fine, and the misfire has happened once in 20 miles since.

                  So, I'll have to get that repaired at some point - I have heard of a place in the North West that is reasonable.

                  Cheers for the good ideas, everyone .


                  And, to cap it all off - the damn car went straight through its MoT today .
                  Rich Smith

                  "Joe", aka "The Ryton Express", aka E838 VJO. Peugeot 309SR main car
                  "Kryten", aka A560 SCW. Left hand drive MG Maestro 1600 'R' second in command
                  "Fleagle", aka F929 NNA. Montego 1.6L saloon stored, status "doubts set in"
                  "Cracow", aka CCW 925Y Maestro Vanden Plas - the oldest known to the Club stored, status "will fight another day - eventually"

                  You can email me here

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by e692wtt
                    Reconnecting the 'original' Ignition ECU got it all working fine, and the misfire has happened once in 20 miles since.

                    So, I'll have to get that repaired at some point - I have heard of a place in the North West that is reasonable.

                    Cheers for the good ideas, everyone .


                    And, to cap it all off - the damn car went straight through its MoT today .
                    Congrats on the MoT Rich!

                    Which Ignition ECU is it? I've got a working 1.6 S-Series one that came off DRY. I've not much use for it these days

                    You can have it if you want it....
                    You can contact me by clicking here.
                    Owner of E760 DRY - Mk. 2 Shantung Gold Maestro Vanden Plas 2.0 EFi

                    If the world should blow itself up, the last audible voice would be that of an expert saying it can't be done. - Sir Peter Ustinov.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Cheers for the congrats on the MoT . And your Ignition ECU? Yes please... I don't know the part number on mine offhand, but if yours is going spare .

                      Oddly enough, after a day of many minor misfires last Wednesday the engine is now running fine and very sweetly minus any signs of misfiring at all (will I regret writing that on the way home?).

                      Bit of a pain keeping it going from cold though, it tends to stall for the first minute but I lowered the fast idle speed when the original fault was prevalent so a reset might be useful :laugh: .
                      Rich Smith

                      "Joe", aka "The Ryton Express", aka E838 VJO. Peugeot 309SR main car
                      "Kryten", aka A560 SCW. Left hand drive MG Maestro 1600 'R' second in command
                      "Fleagle", aka F929 NNA. Montego 1.6L saloon stored, status "doubts set in"
                      "Cracow", aka CCW 925Y Maestro Vanden Plas - the oldest known to the Club stored, status "will fight another day - eventually"

                      You can email me here

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X